One thing that Maggie Stiefvater did really well that Twilight lacks in is having two first person narratives as Denise and Tara mentioned. I really enjoy when authors do this because it allows readers to come up with different thoughts and opinions on characters actions and such; it makes the story more appealing because you hear multiple sides of the story.
The descriptive language that Stiefvater uses, especially in Grace's chapters, read a lot like Bella's in Twilight. She uses a lot of adjectives; it is very whimsical to read. Grace, like Bella again, seem to be overly dramatic. In both there openings in their books, they talk about "I was dying." Then, literally, a sentence later they state: "...but I wasn't dead." I could see how YA females would relate to this because I thought everything at that age was life and death, but in these instances, it is true because they are dealing with extreme circumstances.
Another character that I think YA will relate to is Beck because he seems like a good guy who just can't make the right choices at all times. A lot of kids can relate to this because being a YA means you are just getting to make a lot of choices on your own, and they will more than likely not always be the right ones.
Of course, there was also the love storyline in it is well. I agree, and had the same thought, as Denise when she said it reminded her of Beauty and the Beast. I too thought how, like Beauty, Grace accepted Sam for who he was at whatever time. I think it is important to have the "happily ever after" ending sometimes because it gives youth hope that love does conquer all.
As a side note, I did a little research and found out that a company picked up the film rights for Shiver. Am I surprised? Not at all. I would enjoy seeing it because, like Twilight, I think the imagery could be really pretty. I also would like to see how Sam, Grace, and Beck are transformed from paper to film.
No comments:
Post a Comment